Joe G
Posts: 12011 Joined: July 2007
|
Quote (stevestory @ Oct. 22 2014,09:26) | Quote (Joe G @ Oct. 22 2014,10:14) | Quote (stevestory @ Oct. 22 2014,09:08) | Quote (Joe G @ Oct. 22 2014,09:27) | Quote (stevestory @ Oct. 22 2014,08:13) | Quote (Joe G @ Oct. 21 2014,20:23) | Quote (stevestory @ Oct. 21 2014,13:21) | Quote (Joe G @ Oct. 21 2014,14:10) | So what, if not mass, makes our universe the size that it is? |
you seem to be alleging that universe size is a function of mass. Can you elaborate on what the function is? |
Answer my question and I will get to yours. |
so you can't. not surprised. |
So YOU can't. Why am I not surprised |
I can talk about the friedmann equations, stress-energy tensors, scalar fields of vacuum energy all you want, but I want to know what you imagine is the size=f(mass) function. Since the universe is expanding, do you believe the total mass is increasing? Or do you think the energy density of empty space is decreasing in accordance with conservation of E? since mass and energy are proportional, if you're right that the size of the universe is proportional to mass, it must be proportional to the vacuum energy of space, right? so is the vacuum energy of space determined, or not? also, how does your function deal with the Vacuum Catastrophe? |
The mass isn't increasing. The mass is what is feeding the expansion. No mass no expansion.
That is why I asked- So what, if not mass, makes our universe the size that it is?
Can there be a universe of nothing? How would you know? |
the size of a car, or a balloon, or a planet, isn't simply determined by it's mass, so why should be the universe? And how can you define a function size=f(mass) when you can't determine the vacuum energy, and therefore the absolute mass?
And if you're saying space has to expand because mass is constant, we'd all like you to show us the GR equations that describe that, because you can't, because it's gibberish. |
LoL! Cars, balloons and planets wouldn't exist without mass.
Why do you avoid the points I made?
Quote | And how can you define a function size=f(mass) when you can't determine the vacuum energy, and therefore the absolute mass? |
You didn't understand anything I said. Pathetic
Quote | And if you're saying space has to expand because mass is constant, |
Never crossed my mind.
-------------- "Facts are Stupid"- Timothy Horton aka Occam's Afterbirth
"Genetic mutations aren't mistakes"-ID and Timothy Horton
Whales do not have tails. Water turns to ice via a molecular code- Acartia bogart, TARD
YEC is more coherent than materialism and it's bastard child, evolutionism
|