Antievolution.org - Antievolution.org Discussion Board -Topic::Otangelo's thread

Otangelo

Posts: 149
Joined: Oct. 2015

Posted: Nov. 19 2015,17:41

Quote (Dr.GH @ Nov. 19 2015,15:07)

Otangelo, I won't keep wasting time offering facts. You have shown that you have no interest in facts.

I do have a question that only you can answer; "What are you trying to do?"

It cannot be to learn anything. It cannot impress the majority of us who are professional scientists. (In my case retired). We either already know the science you have garbled, or we have enough education to read the science. Unlike you we can understand what we read.

Are you just jerking off to the attention you have gotten?

Doctor G

i wonder what you have to say about this.

Chlorophyll biosynthesis is a complex pathway with 17 highly specific steps, of which eight last steps are used by specific enzymes uniquely in this pathway.

Even if we find in the sequence space the right steps to make the enzymes required to permit the synthesis of the products of these intermediate steps, so what ? the intermediate products would have no function, and no survival advantage of the organism would be provided. Natural selection could not operate to favor a system with anything less than all seventeen enzymes being present, functioning and processing all intermediate products to get the final product. What evolutionary process could possibly produce complex sophisticated enzymes that generate nothing useful until the whole process is complete? And even if everything were in place correctly, and chlorophyll were synthesized correctly, so what ? Unless chlorophyll AND all other proteins and protein complexes were fully in place, fully evolved and functional, correctly interlocked and working in a interdependent manner, photosynthesis would not happen. But even if photosynthesis would happen, so what ? Why would the organism chose such a extremely complex mechanism, if it was surviving just fine previously ? Furthermore, you do not just need the right enzymes. For the assembly of a biological system of multiple parts, following steps must be explained : the origin of the genome information to produce all subunits and assembly cofactors. Parts availability, synchronization, manufacturing and assembly coordination through genetic information, and interface compatibility. The individual parts must precisely fit together. All these steps are better explained through a super intelligent and powerful designer, rather than mindless natural processes by chance, or / and evolution, since we observe all the time minds capabilities producing machines and factories, producing machines and end products.

everything *has* to be in place at once or else an organism has no survival advantage. The thing is, there’s no driver for any of the pieces to evolve individually because single parts confer no advantage in and of themselves. The necessity for the parts of the system to be in place all at once is simply evidence of creation. Photosynthesis missing one piece (like chlorophylls) is like a car missing just one piece of the drive train (such as a differential); it’s not that it doesn’t function as well – it doesn’t function at all!

someotherguy

Posts: 398
Joined: Aug. 2006

	Antievolution.org :: Antievolution.org Discussion Board The Critic's Resource on Antievolution