Mike PSS
Posts: 428
Joined: Sep. 2006
|
Ftk,
I've asked a simple question that doesn't involve technical scientific knowledge, only author intent.
"Why do you feel the need to challange the present scientific understanding about the Oort cloud?"
What is it about the present explanation that you disagree with?
Lenny gave an answer from his old playbook but I would like to hear it from you.
The reason I ask is simple. For you, or me, or anyone to challange an established principle (like the existence of the Oort cloud) there must be some overwhelming reason to put this challange forward. In scientific investigation (read research) the reason to challange established, published, principles is usually because of evidence or scholorship that shows the past principles lacking in explanatory power w.r.t. the most recent discoveries.
Now, WHY do YOU feel the need to challange the existence of the Oort cloud?
You could even C&P from the sources that you use, but I think it's reasonable for me to ask this.
|
