Skip navigation.
The Critic's Resource on AntiEvolution

NCSE Evolution Education Update for 2010/04/30

(by NCSE Deputy Director Glenn Branch)

Dear Friends of NCSE,

Chris Comer's appeal was heard by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals,
and Eugenie C. Scott received the Public Welfare Medal from the
National Academy of Sciences. Plus a variety of new articles and
videos from NCSE staff.


A three-judge panel from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals heard
arguments in Comer v. Scott on April 26, 2010. Chris Comer was forced
to resign her post as director of science at the Texas Education
Agency in November 2007 after she forwarded a note announcing a talk
by Barbara Forrest; according to a memorandum recommending her
dismissal, "the TEA requires, as agency policy, neutrality when
talking about evolution and creationism." She filed suit in June 2008,
arguing that the policy violates the Establishment Clause of the First
Amendment. The case was dismissed on March 31, 2009, but Comer
appealed the decision to the Fifth Circuit.

In a report from the Associated Press (April 26, 2010), Douglas
Mishkin, one of Comer's lawyers, explained that the policy violates
the Establishment Clause by in effect endorsing a religious belief:
"It takes something that's not science and treats it as if it is."
Fortunato Benavides, one of the judges on the Fifth Circuit panel,
seemed skeptical, however, commenting, "I can see a free speech claim
... This looks like to me a First Amendment claim in the robe of an
establishment claim." It is not known when the panel will issue its
ruling. Documents from the case are available on NCSE's website, and a
brief video about the case is available on NCSE's YouTube channel.

For the Associated Press story, visit: 

For documents from the case, visit: 

For NCSE's YouTube channel, visit: 


NCSE's executive director Eugenie C. Scott received the Public Welfare
Medal from the National Academy of Sciences in a ceremony on April 25,
2010, in Washington DC. According to a January 11, 2010, press
release, "the medal is presented annually to honor extraordinary use
of science for the public good"; Scott was chosen "for championing the
teaching of evolution in the United States and for providing
leadership to the National Center for Science Education."

Accepting the medal, Scott said, "That an organization comprised of
the finest scientists in the nation would bestow this award on a
small, underfunded, understaffed, nonprofit laboring to defend the
teaching of evolution is both humbling and inspiring. On behalf of all
the people who have worked at NCSE over the last 22 years to make it
an effective organization, I thank you from the bottom of my heart."
(A transcript of her remarks is available on NCSE's website.)

Previous recipients include Neal Lane, Norman Borlaug, Maxine F.
Singer, C. Everett Koop, and Carl Sagan. The National Academy of
Sciences is a private, nonprofit institution that was established
under a congressional charter signed by President Abraham Lincoln in
1863. It recognizes achievement in science by election to membership,
and provides science, technology, and health policy advice to the
federal government and other organizations.

For the January 11, 2010, press release, visit: 

For the full text of Scott's remarks, visit: 


NCSE's Joshua Rosenau was asked by the Washington Post to comment on a
chapter about evolution in a new book accusing "the liberal media" of
attacking Christianity. The author's "handling of science and religion
misrepresents the nature of evolution, obscures the science of biology
and dismisses the deeply held religious views of most Christians
outside of the fundamentalist subculture," Rosenau explained. A short
version of his response appeared in the April 25, 2010, issue of the
newspaper, with a long version appearing on the Post's Political
Bookworm blog on April 21, 2010.

For the short version, visit: 

For the long version, visit: 


"Dobzhansky was right: Let's tell the students." That's NCSE's
executive director Eugenie C. Scott's advice, as just published in the
journal BioEssays (2010; 32 [5]: 372-374). "University instructors are
responsible for a good part of the general public's ignorance about
evolution," she argues: "it is they who teach the university students
who become the science teachers in our schools, as well as the
students who become members of the educated public. University
scientists therefore have a special responsibility -- and opportunity
-- to help to cope with the antievolution problem in the United

First and foremost, she recommends that university scientists "think
about how they teach evolution. Is evolution as central, integrated,
and pervasive in their syllabus as it is in biologic research? Will
their students realize that -- in the words of Theodosius Dobzhansky's
famous 1973 article for high school biology teachers ... -- nothing in
biology makes sense except in the light of evolution?" She adds, "If
university instructors do not make explicit the centrality of
evolution to biology, we should not be surprised when students
complete their courses ignorant of evolution."

Beyond the classroom, she urges, "scientists need to speak up when
evolution is under attack in their schools. And more generally,
scientists have a special responsibility to work to ensure a
scientifically literate citizenry, which includes educating them in
the importance of evolution to science, and in science education. In a
nation where the majority of financial and institutional support for
science predominantly depends on the public, it is in the best
interests of neither science nor our nation that the public
understanding of a major principle of science continues in its
dismally low state."

For Scott's essay, visit: 


Three videos featuring NCSE's executive director Eugenie C. Scott have
recently been added to NCSE's YouTube channel. First, a
mini-documentary on Scott's life and work, produced in 2008 by the
University of California, San Francisco, to complement the ceremony in
which she received the UCSF Medal, the university's highest honor.
Second, a talk on "Evolution versus Creationism" that she delivered at
a course on "Darwin's Legacy" at Stanford University in 2008. And
third, "In the Beginning," a discussion among Scott, Francisco Ayala,
and Denis Lamoureux, hosted by NPR's Neal Conan, in Columbus, Ohio, in
2009. Tune in and enjoy!

For NCSE's YouTube channel, visit: 

Thanks for reading! And don't forget to visit NCSE's website -- -- where you can always find the latest news on 
evolution education and threats to it.


Glenn Branch
Deputy Director
National Center for Science Education, Inc.
420 40th Street, Suite 2
Oakland, CA 94609-2509
510-601-7203 x310
fax: 510-601-7204

Subscribe to NCSE's free weekly e-newsletter: 

NCSE is on Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter: 

NCSE's work is supported by its members. Join today!