Joe G
Posts: 12011 Joined: July 2007
|
Quote (fnxtr @ Jan. 22 2011,00:31) | Quote (didymos @ Jan. 21 2011,22:10) | More fun with Joe and arachnids over at UD: Quote | A spider web is natural in that it exists in nature. However nature, operating freely, did not produce it.
I would say a spider web was a product of the intentional actions of a spider.
IOW when I see a spider web I know a spider had been there and left traces of its involvement behind. |
Nice to see "nature, operating freely" make an appearance. I also love the presentation of "spiders make spider webs" as though it were some masterful feat of design detection. |
So a spider making a web isn't "nature, operating freely"? WTF?? Spiders aren't natural? How do you know spiders have "intent"? What part of the spider brain have you been studying?
.. and if you'd never seen or heard of a spider, what then?
You wouldn't just say "this looks designed" and refuse to investigate further, or simply attribute it to a Magic Web Deity, would you?
I dunno, maybe you would.
Me, I'd say "Whoa, how'd this get here!?"
... and would discover it was perfectly natural. Made by something perfectly natural, by natural means.
See, Joe, how this is different from "Sometime, somewhere, somehow, somebody did something"? |
No, a spider is not nature, operating freely. Are you really that stupid?
Do you think my car is from nature, operating freely too?
As I told the asshole over on UD if you ever get any evidence that nature, operating freely can produce a living organism from non-living matter then you will have a point. Until then all organisms are agencies and they usually leave traces of their involvement behind.
-------------- "Facts are Stupid"- Timothy Horton aka Occam's Afterbirth
"Genetic mutations aren't mistakes"-ID and Timothy Horton
Whales do not have tails. Water turns to ice via a molecular code- Â Acartia bogart, TARD
YEC is more coherent than materialism and it's bastard child, evolutionism
|