oldmanintheskydidntdoit
Posts: 4999 Joined: July 2006
|
Quote (Richard Simons @ Jan. 10 2009,21:27) | Daniel, could you answer some questions for me about front-loading?
Do all existing organisms come from one original front-loaded organism or does each organism represent the current end-point of an unbranched line from an ancestral progenitor?
If each current organism represents the end of a lineage, does this mean that, for example, for each of the current species of finch on the Galapagos Islands there was at least one pair of founder birds? Similarly, for every vertebrate species (extant and extinct) was there at least a pair of ancestral chordate, apparently identical but in practice not breeding with others that were destined to give rise to different species?
Alternatively, if branching is possible, what happens when a pair of species diverges? How do they know which one is destined to become rapidly extinct and which one is going to proliferate? Presumably in the one that's going to become extinct the switches you imagine to be present get deleted, permanently switched off or bypassed, or perhaps all the genes that are not needed for the future become deleted. At the reptile/mammal split, was it that in the first line all the genes for hair, elephant tusks, beaver tails and whale fins were flagged for deletion while in the second line it was the genes for feathers, uric acid excretion, poison fangs, neck frills and ichthyosaur tails that were switched off? How was it specified that the correct sets were all switched off? Of course, perhaps there were mistakes and birds were supposed to produce milk :-) How would we know?
Once an organism has passed through a stage do the genes responsible for it get deleted or are they still there but are now bypassed?
Could it be possible to determine the evolutionary future of an organism by examining its genes?
Has any front-loader ever made any attempt to answer questions like these and if so, what conclusion did they come to? Has it even occured to any champion of front-loading that these are the kinds of questions that need to be answered? |
Daniel, So, frontloading is being discussed and some reasonable questions being asked regarding it.
Now, will you ignore them or respond?
If you ignore them you simply solidify your reputation.
If you attempt to answer them in good faith, well, who knows what could happen..
After all, as the resident expert on frontloading (you cited the relevant papers) if you can't answer these questions then who will?
-------------- I also mentioned that He'd have to give me a thorough explanation as to *why* I must "eat human babies". FTK
if there are even critical flaws in Gauger’s work, the evo mat narrative cannot stand Gordon Mullings
|