stevestory
Posts: 13407 Joined: Oct. 2005
|
Quote (guthrie @ Mar. 28 2008,18:40) | Quote (stevestory @ Mar. 28 2008,13:42) | Simply telling people to avoid the troll never ever works. As long as a small fraction of viewers want to aggressively argue with trolls it'll drown out everything else. To fix the problem you have to make it easy for the others to avoid the troll-related material. Say, have a selection like View Trolls / Hide Trolls, and have a few regulars empowered to mark subthreads with a Troll identifier. |
I rather like the sound of that. Surely it is possible with all the modern technology available nowadays? |
Slashdot has a system like that. The posts there get a 1 rating to start, and trusted users can add rating points, and meta-trusted users can evaluate the trusted users, and trolling earns you negative points, and a visitor can select what level of comments he wants to see. So, for instance, if a post has 1,000 comments, it might have
comments / rating 1,000 -1 543 0 345 1 301 2 288 3 45 4 16 5
and the user preference allows you to see comments above whatever rank you choose. Years ago I set my Slashdot settings to 4, and haven't looked back. Really cuts down on the signal to noise ratio. I'm an advocate of using this kind of thing on PT/AtBC, but I'm not work-brickle (how's THAT for an obscure idiom!) enough to help them implement it here. But the advantage is clear. If you have, say, a post on how research on cat coprolites helps explain exactly when cats were first semi-domesticated, and FL puts up a post saying "Charles Darwin was a big cat turd", you can adjust your settings so that you miss the ensuing festival, and only hear the smart and funny people. At the same time, it weakens claims of censorship, because the comments are still available, just marked as stupid. It is kind of annyoing on PT that when a comment section goes ballistic, it is almost always as a result of a creationist saying really stupid things, and not as a result of smart discourse.
Edited by stevestory on Mar. 30 2008,03:50
|