RSS 2.0 Feed

» Welcome Guest Log In :: Register

    
  Topic: Beware: Creationist books for kids (and not from A, anti-evolution< Next Oldest | Next Newest >  
Peter Henderson



Posts: 298
Joined: Aug. 2007

(Permalink) Posted: April 15 2009,05:29   

Creationist material for kids which isn't from AiG, believe it or not !

A book review from the New York Times by Gregory Cowles:

http://papercuts.blogs.nytimes.com/2009....t-fable

 
Quote
William Steig’s Creationist Fable

By Gregory Cowles

Now that my son is learning to read — happy day! — he has the same question for me that my older acquaintances often do: what books do I recommend? But being a book review editor, or a dad, doesn’t make it any easier to match reader to title; and on our last family trip to the library, I fell back helplessly on the early-reader authors I knew from my own childhood. “William Steig!” I said, grabbing an unfamiliar picture book. “He wrote ‘Shrek’! And ‘The Amazing Bone’! And ‘Sylvester and the Magic Pebble’! You’ll love him!” (Against my better instincts and the current recommendations of the American Academy of Pediatrics, I often use exclamation points when I talk to my children. Accents and funny voices too.)

The book I had grabbed was called “Yellow & Pink.” In it, a couple of carved wooden figures awaken in a field and start talking about how they came to exist. Someone must have made us, says Pink. Ridiculous, says Yellow: I think we’re the result of a series of happy accidents that took place over millions of years.

It is, in other words, a picture book about creationism and evolution. And the farther you read, the clearer it is that Steig is on the side of the creationists. As a proponent of evolution, Yellow comes off looking addled and self-important, his claims increasingly far-fetched. Pink even raises that old intelligent-design objection: how could our eyes be an accident, huh? To cap it, on the final page a woodcarver approaches the two, checks to make sure their paint is dry, then tucks them under his arm and walks off. Who’s this guy? Pink asks. I have no idea, Yellow says.

It’s not the pro-religion stance that bothers me here so much as it is the anti-science one. Steig sets up evolution as a straw man, and gleefully knocks it down. Little surprise, then, that “Yellow & Pink” turns up on various intelligent-design reading lists. And little surprise that from now on we’ll stick to “Shrek” in our household.


You have been warned !

  
Schroedinger's Dog



Posts: 1691
Joined: Jan. 2009

(Permalink) Posted: April 15 2009,06:10   

Quote
Little surprise, then, that “Yellow & Pink” turns up on various intelligent-design reading lists


HAHAHA!!! Of course it does, that's about the level of litterature these guys can grasp!

--------------
"Hail is made out of water? Are you really that stupid?" Joe G

"I have a better suggestion, Kris. How about a game of hide and go fuck yourself instead." Louis

"The reason people use a crucifix against vampires is that vampires are allergic to bullshit" Richard Pryor

   
FrankH



Posts: 525
Joined: Feb. 2009

(Permalink) Posted: April 15 2009,09:34   

Finally, a "peer reviewed" piece of creationist literature!

Still, I bet even the target audience would find it "simplistic" and "vacuous".

--------------
Marriage is not a lifetime commitment, it's a life sentence!

  
  2 replies since April 15 2009,05:29 < Next Oldest | Next Newest >  

    


Track this topic Email this topic Print this topic

[ Read the Board Rules ] | [Useful Links] | [Evolving Designs]