Joined: Jan. 2012
Heavens, I go out for a few hours and it all goes pear-shaped! Why are we shooting for the moon now? Has Jupiter disappeared?
|Quote (noncarborundum @ Feb. 14 2012,18:46)|
|Noam, no one will be banned from this site for criticizing ID, and I have no idea where you got such a notion. Go back and read the OP. Only those who demonstrate beyond the slightest doubt that they do not intend to act in good faith (by denying the LNC) will be banned under the new policy. It has everything to do with whether a person is a fool or a charlatan, not whether they criticize ID.|
Seriously. Why hasn't ScottAndrews2 been banned, then?
Strickerly speaking, Scott asked the question of himself, and answered "Yes". He answered No when Barry asked him directly. Under the terms of moderation policy 3Bc subsection 7, Scott lowered his eyes before the jabbing finger and gimlet eye of the Grand Inquisitor, which is the correct response, even though contradictory to his previous statement. I've got a bit of time for Scott, though - and funny enough, I'd probably answer "No" too, were it not for the fact that annoying that staunch defender of logical argumentation BA is far more fun.
Kudos to ben h. He appears to be a Christian (though Barry seems unaware, and anybody could be anything really), and had earlier suggested that he would not cast aspersions at a brother in "Christ's honesty". He might have been being sarcastic, of course.
If hail is made out of ice and ice came from ice via water, then hail is made out of ice. Joe G
BTW, when you make little jabs like â€śI thought basic logic was one thing UDers could handle,â€ť you come off looking especially silly when you turn out to be wrong. - Barry Arrington