JAM
Posts: 517 Joined: July 2007
|
[quote=Daniel Smith,Nov. 18 2007,19:19] [quote=JAM,Nov. 18 2007,15:30] Quote (Daniel Smith @ Nov. 18 2007,15:08) | Quote (JAM @ Nov. 17 2007,10:30) | 1) MET makes clear, testable predictions about the mechanisms by which the messy, fuzzy nature of our genome came about. |
As far as I can see, the only thing messy or fuzzy about our genome is our understanding of it. |
Mine's a helluvalot less fuzzy than yours. May I take it that you conceded all of the other points in choosing a one-liner?[/quote] No.[/quote] Then maybe you should respond. Quote | Quote | I'm particularly interested in your answers to these questions: A) Do you predict that whales will be missing a hind-leg gene? | Not necessarily - though I predict it will be suppressed as to it's full development. |
Genes don't "develop." Organisms and organs do. Please define "it" in this context. Does your hypothesis predict that there will be anything that we humans could call a "hind-leg gene" based on analogies with our own designs? Quote | IOW, the non-coding "support cast" for that gene will be markedly different from animals that have fully developed hind legs. |
Please define "markedly" in this context. It's important. Quote | Quote | Do you predict that monkeys have a tail gene that humans lack? | No. I predict that their "tail gene(s)" (at least the protein coding parts) may be similar to ours, but all their various regulatory and support elements will be markedly different from ours. |
Does your hypothesis predict that there will be anything that we humans could call a "tail gene" based on analogies with our own designs? Quote | Theirs will have much more activity and development |
Again, the term "development" is gibberish in this context, and "activity" means transcriptional activity in this context. Is that what you mean? Quote | in these non-coding areas - possibly evidenced by a markedly higher level of histone activity. |
What do you mean by "histone activity"? Again, it's important. Quote | Ours will be suppressed. |
Our what, exactly? It has to be measurable. Please provide units. Quote | Quote | Both of these stream from your guess as to what God was thinking when he designed, but you are afraid to pursue it, because you have no real faith (Note that this relates to the fuzziness that you lack the integrity to address). | Why does every response from you have to be so peppered with accusations? |
Sit down and take a deep breath. Think, as a Christian, for a moment about what YOU are accusing me and the other scientists of doing here. YOU are accusing US of gross incompetence, and in direct contradiction of clear Biblical guidance, you have made this accusation on the basis of nothing but hearsay. Quote | It gets tiring after awhile. |
Put yourself in my shoes, Dan. I've spent most of my life doing biology, and you come along. Would you describe your claims as humble ones? Quote | I feel like I'm answering you not so much because I have to defend my positions, but rather because I have to defend my character. |
What sort of character makes grandiose claims without evidence, and then discounts the evidence? Quote | Quote | B) I have a gene, and both mice and humans homozygous for the null allele die shortly after birth (with essentially the same phenotype). Since according to you, transcription implies function, when I look at transcription of that gene, will it be turned on: 1) right before the age of death in the null mutants, 2) right before or at the time at which mutants can be distinguished from wild-type individuals, or 3) more than a month before 1 or 2? | I'm not sure what you mean by "when I look at transcription of that gene, will it be turned on". Do you mean "will transcription of that gene be turned on", or will "the gene itself be turned on"? |
The former. Quote | Because I think transcription of the gene will always be happening, |
Why would you think that? WTF do transcription factors do? Quote | but as to when exactly the gene gets turned on, I have no clue. |
Why not? Wouldn't an intelligent designer design it so transcription was turned on when (and where) it was needed, and not before or in other tissues? Quote | Quote | C) Why is it that you are so breathtakingly arrogant that you believe that God causes millions of children to suffer and die as a lesson to people like you, but getting you to make predictions is like pulling teeth? |
The suffering of these children (and everything else that happens in life) is a lesson for us all - not just for "people like me". |
I'm sorry, but I don't see what the children who suffer and die are learning. Why shouldn't you and your children be suffering and dying?
|