RSS 2.0 Feed

» Welcome Guest Log In :: Register

Pages: (356) < [1] 2 3 4 5 6 ... >   
  Topic: Uncommonly Dense Thread 4, Fostering a Greater Understanding of IDC< Next Oldest | Next Newest >  
CeilingCat



Posts: 1659
Joined: Dec. 2007

(Permalink) Posted: Nov. 15 2012,06:31   

The power of Absolute Morality.  I never realized how useful Absolute Morality was until I skimmed through Libby Anne (Part 2) by vjtorley.  Here's an outstanding example:            
Quote
The second thing Libby Anne needs to know about utilitarians is this: their ideology tends to make them adopt views that any sane person would deem morally monstrous. If you want to know where utilitarianism leads, take a look at ex-preacher Dan Barker, who now says (see this video) that child rape could be morally justifiable, if it were absolutely necessary in order to save humanity. The scenario Barker is considering here is one where an evil and technologically advanced alien says he’ll destroy humanity if you don’t rape a child. Because Barker is an act utilitarian, he says he would comply with the alien’s request, although to his credit, he admits that he’d hate himself for doing so. I have to say that while watching the video, I was deeply impressed with Dan Barker’s honesty and his obvious aversion to the idea of performing such a hideous deed. Nevertheless, his utilitarian moral principles are perverse if they lead him to adopt the conclusion that child rape could be moral in an extreme situation.

I guess that's where Christians have an advantage over us atheists.  Because of my fallen morality, I would've said that it was better to rape a child than kill all seven billion plus humans on earth, including the child.  

I do have one tiny caveat - I haven't looked at Barker's video, but I'm guessing that he would not have called child rape "moral", I think he would have said it was something like seven billion times less immoral than killing everybody on earth including the child.  But of course, I'm just a fallen sinner.  I'm sure that if I had absolute morality, I would have done the right thing and just told that mean ol' alien to kill everybody.  Including that un-raped child.

I must confess to one other tiny caveat:            
Quote

Now suppose instead that the evil alien says he’ll destroy humanity if a pregnant woman who wants an abortion doesn’t carry her pregnancy to term. According to Barker, the woman would be morally bound to do what the alien says. It would be her duty not to have an abortion, and it would be our duty to enforce the alien’s wishes and to physically prevent her from having an abortion, for the good of society. I can’t imagine that Libby Anne would accept that conclusion.

I haven't spoken to Libby Anne and, in fact, I have no idea who she is, but I think her whole point is that she puts human beings above fetal flesh.  If so, then I think she would carry the fetus to term in order to save seven billion plus human beings.  But of course, I'm just a fallen atheist sinner, so what do I know.  Perhaps vj could ask her before speaking for her?  Oh wait, it's too late for that.

P.S. I wonder what that "evil and technologically advanced alien" who is ready to murder everybody on earth's name is?  Could it be .... Yahwah?  Naah.  Yahwah didn't kill everybody on earth.  He saved Noah and his family.

--------------
Like every other academic field, philosophy of religion has its share of hacks and mediocrities.   Edward Feser

‘Anything is a “real possibility” in the mind of one seeking to deny the obvious.’ – William J Murray

  
  10669 replies since Aug. 31 2011,21:06 < Next Oldest | Next Newest >  

Pages: (356) < [1] 2 3 4 5 6 ... >   


Track this topic Email this topic Print this topic

[ Read the Board Rules ] | [Useful Links] | [Evolving Designs]