Joined: Jan. 2006
|Premise 1: If atheism is true, then so is Darwinian evolution.|
Premise 2: But if ID is true, then Darwinian evolution is false.
Premise 3: ID is true (the controversial premise).
Conclus 1: Therefore Darwinian evolution is false (modus ponents applied to Premises 2 and 3)
Conclus 2: Therefore atheism is false (modus tollens applied to Premise 1 and Conclus 1)
IOW Dembski proves that:
ID, if true (controversial), implies that God(s) exist.
Hmmm IIRC, ID does not require a deity; It could be aliens.
| It keeps us honest.|
I have no problem with "It".