Joined: Feb. 2008
|Quote (skeptic @ Mar. 12 2008,21:20)|
|no God doesn't tell Job that I'm bigger than you, he says I can't tell you because you just wouldn't understand. it is beyond human capacity. As is apparent by your oversimplification. Who are you to say what is and isn't God's plan when you see such a tiny part of it?|
If Gods plan is incomprehensible, how is that different (for us) from a universe that is just incomprehensible without God ? If anything at all can happen and still be part of Gods plan, what would make you believe there is a God, never mind one with the specific attributes given in a particular book* ?
If he is really incomprehensible, why would you believe the bible was really his word ? Maybe it's a test to sort out the gullible from those capable of rational observation ?
What objective criteria allows you to decide God is the God of the bible and not the daemon sultan Azathoth Or Zeus ? Or Loki ? Or Shiva or FSM ?
|Quote (skeptic @ Mar. 13 2008,14:42)|
|this is like listening to a child reason, in fact I think I heard my six year old say nearly the same thing when I told him not to touch the hot stove.|
Except that if your son touched the stove, he would have burned himself, and learned something about the accuracy of your advice. OTOH, following or not following alleged word of God has, by and large, no significant observable relationship to getting burned or not.
* Which by objective observation appears to be collected myths of some middle eastern tribesmen as heard through a multi-millennia game of telephone, and has about the accuracy and information content you'd expect to result from this exercise.