Wesley R. Elsberry
Posts: 4991
Joined: May 2002
|
| Quote (GaryGaulin @ Sep. 24 2017,14:42) | | Quote (Wesley R. Elsberry @ Sep. 24 2017,13:02) | | The prime examples in Gary's stuff being the complete lack of anything that looks like an implementation of a Trehub neural model (look, Ma, no comb filters!) and the complete absence of Heiserman "gamma" processes. |
The simplified block diagram is representative of both "Beta" and "Gamma", as well as ONE ILLUSTRATION from Arnold Trehub showing the same basic interconnections. There should be no issue with my crediting who I learned it from, and evidence that the system will also work for generating human level intelligence.
I am not obligated to prove that every prediction that the authors ever made are all true. I already have way more work than I can finish in one lifetime and should now be working on the ID Lab. |
The block diagram isn't Gary's code. Gary's code defines what Gary is using. Gary specifically disavowed any need to actually use Heiserman "gamma" processes earlier, and also specifically disavowed actually having to implement *any* neural network, much less Trehub's specific model.
Citing people is a fine thing. However, merely dropping a bibliographic entry into the citation list and name-dropping something in the text does not automatically transfer *any* credence or authority from the cited person.
| Quote |
I am not obligated to prove that every prediction that the authors ever made are all true.
|
Nobody has asked Gary to do any such thing. All I've requested is that Gary demonstrate that the specific ideas he relies upon are of current utility to others beside himself. Gary is having a very difficult time doing something that should be utterly simple, would that he were relying on things that could be described as something other than "old junk".
--------------
"You can't teach an old dogma new tricks." - Dorothy Parker
|
