GaryGaulin
Posts: 5385
Joined: Oct. 2012
|
| Quote (N.Wells @ Oct. 05 2015,07:33) | | Quote (GaryGaulin @ Oct. 05 2015,06:32) | | Quote (N.Wells @ Oct. 05 2015,06:04) | | No one says your model has to compose a symphony, but it is crazy to define intelligence in such a way that composing a symphony can be excluded from being an act of intelligence. |
You ignored almost everything I said. And I don't have the time or resources to write an ID Lab that composes music, along with all else I'm trying to finish.
I have to go do a "civic duty". Jury duty. No time to waste. |
You have that backward. I read what you wrote and responded, but you misread what I said. No one is asking you to write a program that composes a symphony. In fact, that's a case in point, because what I said was, "No one says that your model has to compose a symphony". What I've been asking is that you create definitions that work, as opposed to ones that are clearly invalid. |
Then how would you (without changing the circuit requirement based format that is already there) prevent someone such as yourself from misinterpreting the operational definition. You need a body to control with "ears" on it to even "hear" a symphony, so requirement 1 is not an inherent problem.
And to explain "Jury duty" to someone who lives under across the pond I found the video (mentioning Pilgrims and Puritans) that we were shown during orientation:
Massachusetts Juror Orientation Video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v....r7ucOUg
Even though having to report is inconvenient and waiting to see whether we're actually needed can be boring (though this time we got to watch the beginning of the Siderman Movie before being told we can go) we're thankful for living where this exists and are later proud of ourselves for showing up Jury Duty. Years ago I was needed to be a juror, but this time the cases were resolved without a jury being needed.
--------------
The theory of intelligent design holds that certain features of the universe and of living things are best explained by an intelligent cause, not an undirected process such as natural selection.
|
