NoName
Posts: 2729
Joined: Mar. 2013
|
| Quote (stevestory @ July 18 2015,12:47) | i'm starting to think BatShit77 really does have some kinda mental illness. He's just repasting the same idiotic shit over and over. I don't even read his comments (does anyone?) and I'm even starting to recognise repeats like this:
| Quote | Existential Argument against Atheism – November 1, 2013 by Jason Petersen
1. If a worldview is true then you should be able to live consistently with that worldview.
2. Atheists are unable to live consistently with their worldview.
3. If you can’t live consistently with an atheist worldview then the worldview does not reflect reality.
4. If a worldview does not reflect reality then that worldview is a delusion.
5. If atheism is a delusion then atheism cannot be true.
Conclusion: Atheism is false. |
linky |
Good god, that's stupid!
Point 1 is unsupported.
Point 2 is blatant, and question begging, assertion, made without support.
Point 3, well, see point 1
Point 4, tautological and useless for this "argument"
Point 5, gigantic leap due to the smuggled-in, hidden premise that it is impossible to be deluded into believing something that turns out to be true. Trivially false, with countless counter-examples readily available.
|
