NoName
Posts: 2729
Joined: Mar. 2013
|
| Quote (GaryGaulin @ June 10 2015,18:52) | | Quote (Jim_Wynne @ June 10 2015,17:21) | | Quote (GaryGaulin @ June 10 2015,17:18) | | Quote (Jim_Wynne @ June 10 2015,11:48) | | On the basis of "scanning" the paper, would you agree with the characterization of the authors as crackpots? Why or why not? |
And no I would not characterize the authors as crackpots. In my opinion they look more like fellow victims of an academic education system that is happy leaving giant gaps in their learning that they will have to fill on their own. |
So you've concluded, based on not having carefully "studied" the paper, that the authors have "giant gaps in their learning"? Where do you see evidence of this? |
I probably studied the paper much better than you did.
If they were properly prepared then they would have had no problem impressing me. |
ROFLMAO
And, as per usual, you're not competent to judge.
|
