Turncoat
Posts: 129
Joined: Dec. 2007
|
| Quote (sledgehammer @ Dec. 13 2009,18:59) | | Quote (Maya @ Dec. 11 2009,13:48) | | Dembski is crowing about getting another article published. Has the IEEE always had such low standards? |
I note that these last two "papers" are conference proceedings.
The IEEE standards for accepting a conference paper and those for publication in one of their journals are vastly different.
Conference papers are accepted purely on the basis of an abstract, with no peer review except by the session chairs, who often have a quota of slots to fill.
Later, after the conference, authors are often invited to submit a "proper" paper for peer review and publication in the appropriate journal.
ETA: I see olegt has already made this point three pages ago! I'm late and lacking, as usual. |
Sorry, but this is simply wrong.
--------------
I never give them hell. I just tell the truth about them, and they think it's hell. — Harry S Truman
|
